Search

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I'll be in touch with you shortly.

Explore My Properties
Silver-shingled Cape house with a small screened porch and cedar deck beside a quiet garden of pitch pines and late-autumn grasses.

The Houses Behind Wellfleet's Monthly Median Price

November 19, 2026

On October 16, three Wellfleet deeds were recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds on the same day. 111 Springbrook Rd. sold for $701,000. 40 Old Gull Pond Rd. sold for $707,500. 195 King Phillip Rd. sold for $2,150,000. On November 10, the Cape Cod & Islands Association of REALTORS released its October report, which put Wellfleet's October median sale price at $701,000, down 11.2% from October 2025.

If you are comparing Outer Cape towns this fall, that 11.2% drop is the number most likely to reach you. It came from 11 sales. In a town where 10 to 13 homes close in a month, the monthly median is close to just the sixth house on a short list. Which houses made that list moves the figure more than any change in what Wellfleet homes are worth. The price data that holds steady runs over longer periods, and it points the other way.

Eleven Sales Make a Median

CCIAOR's October 2026 market report, built from Cape Cod MLS data updated through November 5, shows 11 Wellfleet sales in October 2026. That was 21.4% fewer than in October 2025, at a median of $701,000 and 40 median days on market. The town table counts every residential sale together, condos included.

The two months before that look like a different market. In September 2026, Wellfleet had 13 sales at a $900,000 median, up 7.3% from a year earlier, with homes taking 61 median days to sell. In August 2026, it had 10 sales at a $949,000 median, down 18.5%, with homes selling in a median of 14 days. August's sales count rose 150% from August 2025. Off a base that small, that means four sales became ten.

So over three straight months, Wellfleet's median went from $949,000 to $900,000 to $701,000, and median days on market went from 14 to 61 to 40. Those swings track the handful of homes that happened to close each month.

October, House by House

The Registry's records show what that handful looked like. The Provincetown Independent prints every Outer Cape deed over $10,000 each week. Here are the Wellfleet home sales it reported as recorded in October 2026, from lowest price to highest:

  1. 420 Chequessett Neck Rd., Unit 10, $405,000, recorded October 7
  2. 50 Ocean View Dr., Unit 14, $630,000, recorded October 19
  3. 111 Springbrook Rd., $701,000, recorded October 16
  4. 40 Old Gull Pond Rd., $707,500, recorded October 16
  5. 45 Old Paine Hollow Rd., $867,000, recorded October 2
  6. 15 Squires Pond Ln., $1,100,000, recorded October 2
  7. 35 Sea Oaks Way, $1,350,000, recorded October 8
  8. 10 Bank St., $1,755,000, recorded October 30
  9. 195 King Phillip Rd., $2,150,000, recorded October 16

That list won't match CCIAOR's 11 sales line for line. The deeds are dated by when they were recorded at the Registry, and the CCIAOR report counts MLS closings. Still, the structure is easy to see. The two unit sales sit at the bottom. Three homes are bunched between $701,000 and $867,000. Above that, prices spread out to $2,150,000.

The middle of the nine recorded deeds is 45 Old Paine Hollow Rd. at $867,000. That is the same figure as CCIAOR's Wellfleet median for all of 2026 through October. The gap between the fourth and fifth houses on the list is $159,500. Move one sale across that gap and the month's median moves by about that much. A month with two condo closings and a cluster of homes near $700,000 gives a $701,000 median. A month with one more house above the cluster gives something close to $867,000, with the same Wellfleet houses still standing on the same streets.

One more October deed shows up in the record. On October 29, 4 Peace Valley Rd. transferred for $200,000 to the Compact of Cape Cod Conservation Trusts. In August, land "Off Route 6" went to the Wellfleet Conservation Trust for $250,000. In Wellfleet's deed record, conservation buyers sit right next to homebuyers. When you read the weekly lists, separate those transfers out before you do any math.

The $5.2 Million Sale That Didn't Lift August

August shows the same effect from the other direction. During the week of August 3 to 7, 615 Chequessett Neck Rd. was recorded at $5,200,000 and 1100 Ocean View Ave. at $3,350,000. Those are two of the largest Wellfleet transfers of the year. Wellfleet's August median still fell 18.5%, to $949,000.

A median only cares about order. A $5.2 million house on Chequessett Neck counts the same as any other sale above the midpoint. That week's deeds also included 20 Big Chief Hill at $295,000 and 25 Whitman Ln. at $630,000. In a ten-sale month, the lower-priced homes do more to set the median than the $5.2 million headline does. A buyer who sees "Wellfleet prices down 18.5%" and expects bargains across town has misread what the figure measures.

September tells the same story. Recorded prices that month ran from $466,666 at 44 Old Salt Ln. to $2,495,000 at 160 Main St. In between were 1125 Ocean View Dr. at $1,825,000, 260 Blue Heron Rd. at $2,000,000, and three unit sales: 260 Kendrick Ave. at $650,000, 100 Hiawatha Rd. at $900,000 and 20 Fresh Brook Ln. at $505,000. When prices range that widely across about a dozen sales, a small change in the mix gives a very different middle.

Price per Square Foot Runs the Other Way

The same CCIAOR table has a better yardstick. In October 2026, Wellfleet homes sold for a median of $573 per square foot, up 2.3% from October 2025. That was in the same month the median sale price fell 11.2%. When price per square foot rises while the median price falls, buyers were paying a little more for each foot of space and simply bought smaller or lower-priced homes.

For 2026 through October, Wellfleet's median price per square foot is $688, up 11.2% from the same period in 2025. Over those ten months, the town recorded 67 sales, up 13.6%, at a median of $867,000, up 1.4%. Median days on market came in at 25, which is 15 days faster than a year earlier. Read together, the year-to-date figures describe a Wellfleet market with more sales, faster sales and higher prices per foot than in 2025. That doesn't match a market losing value. October's $573 per square foot sits well below the $688 year-to-date figure because of the homes that closed that month.

Truro and Eastham Show the Same Pattern

The effect weakens as a town's sample grows. Truro had 8 sales in October 2026 at a $609,000 median, with homes taking 151 median days to sell. For 2026 through October, Truro's median is $885,000 on 60 sales, with 48 median days on market. The town's October median is $276,000 below its year-to-date median, and October's days-on-market figure is about three times the year-to-date one. Eight sales can do that.

Eastham's numbers hold together better. Its October 2026 median was $829,000 on 13 sales, and its median for 2026 through October is $827,000 on 83 sales. The October figure happened to match the year-to-date one. Larger towns look steadier on the same chart. For 2026 through October, Provincetown has 123 sales at a $1,245,000 median, and Orleans has 100 sales at $862,500. When you compare towns, use the year-to-date columns for all of them. That way you're comparing price levels, and the size of each town's sample matters less.

Reading Wellfleet's Numbers Before You Make an Offer

Next week, October is still the latest month CCIAOR has published, and the $701,000 figure will keep showing up in market summaries. Start with three numbers from that same report: the $867,000 year-to-date median, the $688 year-to-date price per square foot, and the 25-day year-to-date median days on market. Those cover 67 sales, which is enough to say something about the town.

Then read the Provincetown Independent's weekly deed lists for the Wellfleet streets you're considering. The November 11 roundup covers deeds recorded November 2 to 6. Its one Wellfleet sale was 30 Bearberry Way at $725,000. A few weeks of those lists will put a price beside a unit on Chequessett Neck Rd., a house on Old Gull Pond Rd. and a house on King Phillip Rd., all recorded in October between $405,000 and $2,150,000. Our Wellfleet neighborhood page has more on the town around those streets.

Sellers should read the numbers the same way. A Wellfleet owner pricing a home this winter should look at the sales most like that home in the deed record. A town median that a couple of unit closings can move doesn't tell you much about your own house. Our home valuation page starts from those comparable sales.

When you're ready to look at the Wellfleet sales that compare to the home you want to buy or sell, Cape & Island Home can go through the recent deeds and MLS closings with you, street by street. Let's Connect.

Follow Us On Instagram